Home / Insights / Blindsided – How Can You End a Conservatorship or Guardianship?

Blindsided – How Can You End a Conservatorship or Guardianship?

December 21, 2023

Michael Oher, a former professional football player, and the main character depicted in the film The Blind Side, has been in the news regarding a conservatorship that was created when he was in high school. Oher states that he believed, and the story told in the movie portrays this, that he was adopted by the Tuohy family, with whom he lived while playing high school football. In fact, the Tuohy’s never formally adopted Oher; instead, they became his conservators, also called guardians in some states. 

What Is A Conservator?

A conservator/guardian is appointed by a court to make decisions for an individual (“conservatee”) who the court believes cannot take care of themselves. Frequently, this is done in the case of someone with dementia or some type of disability that makes them unable to care for themselves. 

The conservator can be appointed over the “person” meaning the conservator is empowered to make decisions for the conservatee regarding medical care, living arrangements, social interactions, and other personal matters. Where assistance is needed with financial matters, a conservator must be appointed over the “property” specifically allowing the conservator to have financial control over the conservatee’s assets and income and the power to pay bills.

Typically, the appointing court will only grant powers to the conservator that constitute the “least restrictive means” necessary so as to protect the individual autonomy of the conservatee.

How Long Does a Conservatorship Last?

As the Oher case demonstrates, conservatorship appointments are of an indefinite duration. This can become problematic when there is a younger, physically healthy person subject to a conservatorship, or when someone who was initially in need of a conservator recovers the ability to manage their affairs as occurred in the Britney Spears matter, another high-profile conservatorship which was recently terminated.

How Can a Conservatorship Be Terminated?

Conservators are appointed by the court. As such, the relationship can only be terminated by a court. This is true even if the conservator and the conservatee are in agreement about ending the conservatorship. If both parties agree to terminate the conservatorship, the process should be relatively straightforward, but if they are not in agreement, a contested court proceeding will likely occur.

In deciding whether to terminate a conservatorship, the court will want evidence that the person under the conservatorship is now capable of managing their own affairs and making their own decisions. This can include testimony from treating physicians, caretakers, or others knowledgeable about the condition and competency of the conservatee.

The court should also be made aware of alternative arrangements that might suffice to address any concerns about the conservatee’s fitness to make decisions, but which are less restrictive than a conservatorship. This may include the use of a power of attorney, appointment of a health care agent and other advance directives, or a supported decision-making arrangement which can be informal or contractual. These alternatives may also be considered before seeking conservatorship initially.

The stakes are high in conservatorship proceedings since restrictions on a person’s autonomy are at issue. If you are a conservator, conservatee, or interested party, contact our firm for assistance. We have extensive experience with these matters and can guide you through the process of obtaining, contesting, or ending a conservatorship. 

FEATURED VIDEO

Smith Legacy Law:
Your Lawyers For Life

Recent Posts

Bound or Unbound: The Status of Non-Compete Clauses for Employees

The U.S. Federal Trade Commission (FTC) recently announced the adoption of regulations barring the use of non-compete clauses in employment relationships. This regulation, expected to go into effect this summer, would effectively void all employer-imposed restrictions...

The Benefits of a Contract to Make a Will

A Will is an essential legal document that sets forth how you want your assets to be distributed upon your death. However, in some instances, your beneficiaries may want extra assurances that they will receive what was promised to them because they are concerned that...

Decanting an Irrevocable Trust

Trusts are one of the most commonly utilized tools in estate planning. A significant benefit of a trust is that it can last for many generations depending on how it is drafted. However, that can also be a downside. Sometimes, due to the evolution of laws and other...

How to Include Charitable Giving in Your Estate Planning

Few people can match the $1 billion donation of Ruth Gottesman to the Albert Einstein School of Medicine endowing the school to be forever tuition-free. However, incorporating charitable giving into your estate planning offers considerable rewards even at...